Be certain of the source before using. Vanilla extract is a baking staple, and one that seems to be called for in nearly every recipe for cookies and cakes — as well as making frequent appearances in numerous other desserts. Vanilla extract comes in different strengths, such as single, double, etc. The best substitution for this common ingredient depends on the recipe in which you want to replace the vanilla extract. Reduce the amount of granulated sugar in the recipe accordingly, if possible, as vanilla extract adds only flavor rather than sweetness. The recipe calls for root beer extract, but I haven't found any locally, and the cost plus shipping on Amazon is a little more than I'd like. (For your shopping convenience, this post contains affiliate links.). 4. I’ve purchased this vanilla powder in the past, so don’t let the price deter you. Variety of shopping guides from Snappy Gourmet including favorite kitchen products, ideas for kids who like to cook, etc. My favorite vanilla substitute is using such things as rum, brandy, or bourbon. Vanilla Powder. 12. Give it a try! Some options include maple syrup, triple sec, almond extract and rum. so keep that in mind that they may not all work for any given recipe. Cover the jar and place in a dark place. To give your recipe a little flavor try different spices such as ground cinnamon or nutmeg, or spice blends such as apple pie or pumpkin pie spice. 1 tablespoon. A great addition to chocolate recipes too. of vanilla extract you would use 1tsp of vanilla flavoring. The problem with vanilla is, when you run out and need to buy a new bottle, you may be in for some sticker shock. Vanilla extract can add extra richness of flavor to many baked goods. 1/2 to 1 teaspoon other extract (such as almond, peppermint, lemon, orange, etc.) Yes, you can absolutely substitute imitation vanilla instead of pure vanilla extract. Fun food that's a snap to make! EXTRACTS Determine the exact amount of vanilla extract in the recipe you wish to make. SODA Each represents a higher concentration of vanilla in the extract. 1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract . COFFEE In other recipes, such as pancakes or banana bread, you can replace vanilla extract with non-vanilla-flavored ingredients. 1. How Can I Make Melting Chocolate With Cocoa Powder? "Pure" means that only vanilla beans have been used to make the vanilla flavor; however, that doesn't mean that you won't find other additives, such as sugar on the ingredient list. You do not need to make any substitutions or changes to the recipe other than those already mentioned. VANILLA SUGAR, PASTE OR POWDER 1 cup lard. Can I use vanilla powder as a substitute for vanilla extract? 4. That’s a bonus! One food blogger with MyRecipes recommends using bourbon in place of vanilla, saying it adds caramel and maple notes to the vanilla flavor (and comes in at about a third the price, ounce for ounce). 9. Home » Other Posts » Misc. FLAVORED MILK Posts » Vanilla Extract Substitutes. Easy recipes from cocktails and appetizers to main dishes and desserts! I have! 11. Do you ever run out of vanilla extract? 10. Fresh zest such as orange, lime, and lemon are also great additions. Maybe a cooking expert could tell the difference. And yes, the alcohol in the booze (as with the alcohol in vanilla extract itself) will burn off in the cooking process, so nobody's going to get too tipsy when they dig in. Cover with 1 cup of vodka making sure the beans are fully submerged. Substitutes. However, The Vanilla.COMpany says ½ vanilla bean is the equivalent of 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract, so the "experts" differ by 50%. Maybe that’s just me? Have you noticed the crazy high prices of vanilla extract lately? This would be great for all my cannoli recipes such as my popular Cannoli Cake and Cannoli Cookies. 7. MAPLE SYRUP Depending on what you’re making, you can generally just omit the vanilla extract if the recipe just calls for just a little bit. You can even boil down the fruit juice to compact the flavor even more. Vanilla prices may be high, but check out other extracts such as almond (one of my favorites! That’s also assuming the vanilla is not the “star” ingredient or flavoring. Maple syrup works well as a replacement for vanilla extract in many recipes, and runs less risk of tasting wrong with the recipe than almond extract, framboise or other distinctly flavored items. IMITATION VANILLA FLAVORING This amount is important regardless of which substitute you use, as it will help you determine how much of the substitute to add to your recipe. 1 teaspoon. Swap like for like by using vanilla beans, paste or powder in your recipe instead. Buying the Best Extract . This flavoring was never exactly cheap, but it seems to have gotten crazy expensive over the past few years. In other words, if your recipe calls for 1 tsp. Posts, Other Posts, Lisa Huff is a Cookbook Author, Freelance Recipe Developer, Food Photographer, Blogger/Writer, and award-winning home chef. SPICES I try to use it sparingly and sometimes I just run out and need some options. How to Substitute for Citric Acid in a Recipe, How to Substitute Vanilla for Vanilla Sugar. 6. Let’s talk about the items that can quickly and easily be used as substitutes for vanilla. 17. Vinegar, Balsamic. I don’t know for sure, but I can’t see that changing anytime soon. 8. There is also a possibly that the Mexican "vanilla concentrate" is not real vanilla and could be dangerous. vanilla extract in the recipe. Here's what you can substitute for vanilla extract. If your recipe calls for 3/4 tsp. Unfortunately, there is no single ingredient that can successfully replace vanilla extract in all its uses. of vanilla extract, replace the extract with vanilla sugar if the vanilla flavor is vitally important to the recipe. OChef: Is There a Simple Substitute for Vanilla? Tags: extract, substitutions, vanilla Categories: Misc. Most extracts can be substituted in the same ratio as vanilla, but for almond extract, which has a strong flavor, you should only use half the recommended amount. 1/2 vanilla bean. If however, you’re making something like vanilla ice cream, you may NOT want to omit the vanilla flavor. 14. Vanilla extract, in comparison, can have a slight edge to the flavor and aroma, a result of the alcohol used to make it. 1 cup. They come in great flavors such as apple, banana cream, champagne, bubble gum, and more! Add this ingredient to the recipe in the same way as you would have added the vanilla. A great vanilla alternative to try! 3. vanilla sugar to replace the 3/4 tsp. Vegetable Shortening, solid. You can also substitute … HONEY Morgan O'Connor has been writing professionally since 2005. You can also try making your own vanilla extract to save yourself a little. We are sharing 17+ of the BEST vanilla extract substitutes! Or even flavored alcohol like vanilla vodka is a great inexpensive option and great for cocktails too. You'll find a few different options on the shelf in the baking aisle, when it comes to vanilla extract: pure extract, imitation extract, and vanilla flavoring. . MAPLE SYRUP Quick, easy, and inexpensive substitute for vanilla extract in most cases. Pair it with some spices or citrus as well. Her experience includes articles on various aspects of the health-insurance industry for health-care newsletters distributed to hospitals as well as articles on both international and domestic travel. Most people also have maple syrup in their home so it’s an easy solution a lot of the time. Thanks, we'll pass. 15 TEA Vanilla flavoring can in fact be substituted 1:1 for vanilla extract. Continue making the recipe as normal. Substitute another flavorful liquid for vanilla extract if you do not have vanilla sugar or if the vanilla flavor is not vital to the recipe. Vanilla extract can add extra richness of flavor to many baked goods. vanilla sugar for each 1/4 tsp. Vanilla prices have been so high lately! Diana's Desserts: Ingredient Substitution Chart. Add the vanilla sugar to the other sugar in the recipe (or to the dry ingredients) rather than mixing it with the wet ingredients. Fruit juice or citrus zest can brighten up a lot of baked goods. Some flavors can be more inexpensive than vanilla. Luckily, however, there are a number of other pantry staples that can be used as less pricey, yet perfectly acceptable, substitutes for vanilla. If you like tea, it can add a unique addition to your dish. glass jar with lid (mason jars works great). Vanilla (or other flavored…) milk, almond milk, or milk substitutes can give a nice flavor for some recipes. Lisa Huff is a cookbook author, recipe developer, food stylist, food photographer, & award-winning home chef. For example, peppermint extract may work well in a sugar cookie recipe, but almond or lemon might be preferable for a fruit pie filling. Use an equal amount of the flavoring of your choice as the vanilla extract in the original recipe. FIORI DI SICILIA If you’re making a big chocolate cake (like my decadent Brownie Cake) and the recipe calls for a small amount of vanilla extract, like a teaspoon, I don’t think most people would notice the difference. While some bakers prefer using vanilla paste or vanilla beans, these can be even pricier, and may be harder to find too — at least at your average non-gourmet supermarket. Not necessarily a great option for all recipes, but honey has a distinct flavor that can brighten up a lot of dishes. While imitation vanilla is an obvious cheap substitute, it's kind of a sketchy one — imitation vanilla is made from vanillin, a chemical compound that can be extracted from substances like coal or wood.